My Spaniel loves these treats, he seems to just like the crunch and the fact that It's not just one Chunk and absent. The resealable packet keeps them refreshing and crunchy. These are an excellent treat, perfectly built with NO artificial components and so they scent identical to peanut butter. https://goodboy-crunchy-chicken-a36800.dm-blog.com/31761882/the-2-minute-rule-for-duck-and-carrot-dog-treats-goodboy